Knowledge and Skills Statement
Task students with sharing an idea that would solve a problem regarded as a class concern. They should be able to clearly explain their idea to the class. Elicit a class discussion to include feedback from peers with reasons why the idea may or may not solve the problem. Have students suggest possible pitfalls of the idea and how the pitfalls might be handled. Alternately, instruct students to listen to the ideas presented by classmates and offer their own feedback. Observe and note whether students are able to participate meaningfully in these class discussions.
Further Explanation
For this SE, students are expected to have a strong enough understanding of a concept to clearly communicate insights or possible points of inquiry about the topic being discussed as they exercise skills in reciprocal communication. Students will need to consider an alternate perspective and whether they believe the points to be sound, worth debating, or in need of further clarification. They should respond with respect, especially when providing opposing opinions or questioning someone else's understanding of a concept. Likewise, students should understand how to respond to critical assessments of their own ideas.
Research
Schunn, C., Godley, A. & DeMartino. (2016). The reliability and validity of peer review of writing in high school AP English classes. Journal of Adolescent and Adult Literacy, 60(1), 13–23. doi: 10.1002/jaal.525
Summary: This study examines peer to peer feedback as a valuable approach to improving academic writing. The process includes reading each others essays and providing critical feedback as directed by a teacher-created rubric, set of questions, or prompt. After students receive the feedback, students may discuss and provide clarification as needed. Students then rewrite or edit the paper based upon the feedback and discussion. This study examines the use of this practice to improve the writing of AP students. The article includes on overview of literature that centers on the value of student feedback. The article also includes multiple charts and the results of the data in which students responded to surveys about the effectiveness of using student feedback.